Introduction

Starling Marte, once known for his speed and power, is facing a turning point in his career with the New York Mets during the 2025 MLB season. Once an All-Star contributor, Marte is now adjusting to a reduced role as he navigates performance challenges, shifting lineups, and contract pressures. This article examines Starling Marte's current status, explores expert opinions, and considers what the future might hold.

Starling Marte’s Performance in 2025

Marte’s start this season has been far from ideal. Through his first 28 games, he has struggled to find his rhythm at the plate. The 36-year-old outfielder, now doing more part-time work, posted a batting average hovering around .192 and an OPS slightly above .600. Despite these struggles, Mets manager Carlos Mendoza has remained supportive. He believes that Marte will break out of his slump, given his history of elite play. Mendoza continues to give Marte opportunities, particularly against left-handed pitchers, hoping that consistency and trust will help him return to form.

For more on Marte's role and Mendoza's perspective, read SNY’s detailed Mets notes.

Adjusting to a Platoon Role

Marte’s time as an everyday starter appears to be over, at least for now. With injuries to other Mets' players, he briefly saw a few extra starts as the designated hitter (DH) and middle-of-the-lineup bat. Yet, manager Mendoza has rotated other players, such as Jeff McNeil and Jesse Winker, into those opportunities as well. When facing right-handed pitchers, Marte often finds himself on the bench. This role change is tough for a veteran used to being in the heart of the lineup every day.

For fantasy baseball fans or those tracking lineup trends, check out RotoWire’s latest on Starling Marte’s playing time.

The Mets and Marte’s Contract

Much of the discussion surrounding Starling Marte now involves his contract. Signed to a four-year, $78 million deal after a stellar 2022, Marte was expected to make a major impact. While he excelled early in his Mets tenure, recent seasons have been marred by injury and inconsistency. In 2025, Marte’s production is not matching his $20 million salary, especially in a limited DH role. The situation is drawing increasing attention both in the media and among fans who are keen for the Mets to justify every spot in their chase for the postseason.

For a detailed breakdown of the contract situation and value analysis, see Fansided’s deep dive into Marte’s contract.

What’s Next for Starling Marte?

While his stolen bases and sprint speed have declined, Marte’s veteran presence and history of clutch performances still command respect. The Mets are giving him time to adjust, perhaps hoping he can recapture past form when the team needs it most. Whether he can bounce back will be key to the Mets’ depth and flexibility throughout the season. As fans and analysts watch closely, Starling Marte’s journey reminds us that even proven stars must find new ways to contribute as circumstances change.

Conclusion

Starling Marte’s 2025 season reflects the realities many veteran players face: adapting to a reduced role, battling through slumps, and managing the pressure of a large contract. The Mets continue to support him, aware that his experience and flashes of skill can still offer valuable contributions. As the season unfolds, all eyes remain on Marte to see if he can turn things around or cede more of the spotlight to younger talent.