Kyle Gibson has long been viewed as a reliable veteran arm in Major League Baseball. After spending the 2024 season with the St. Louis Cardinals, he entered 2025 with many questions swirling about his future. As Gibson adapts to his new role with the Baltimore Orioles, both fans and analysts are weighing the impact of his recent performances and the decisions made by the Cardinals in the offseason.

The Cardinals’ Decision to Move On

The St. Louis Cardinals faced tough choices last winter. With a surplus of pitching talent and an eye on the future, they ultimately decided to part ways with both Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson. Many fans debated this decision, especially after Gibson’s dependable 2024 campaign. However, the front office's move appears justified in hindsight. Since departing St. Louis, Gibson has experienced a challenging start, which you can read about in depth in Cardinals Fan-Favorite's Ice-Cold Start Has Justified Decision.

The Cardinals' pitching rotation has excelled without Gibson, ranking highly in ERA, innings pitched, and overall value. Meanwhile, the Orioles took a low-risk gamble by signing him to a one-year deal, hoping his veteran presence would help steady their injury-riddled staff.

Kyle Gibson’s Rough Start in Baltimore

Gibson’s transition to the Orioles has not gone as planned. His 2025 season began late, and through his first three starts, opponents have found tremendous success at the plate. Gibson has posted a 13.11 ERA over just 11 2/3 innings, surrendering seven home runs and 17 earned runs. These struggles have highlighted why his market was quiet in the offseason. For a full breakdown of Gibson’s recent difficulties and how it reflects on his former team, visit Former Cardinals pitcher's stock has reached an all-time low since leaving St. Louis.

Despite these numbers, the Orioles are sticking by Gibson for now. With key pitching prospects still recovering from injuries and the rotation in flux, Baltimore is hoping Gibson can rediscover his rhythm. Local analysis at BaltimoreBaseball.com outlines the Orioles' thought process, emphasizing that cutting Gibson and fellow veteran Charlie Morton would yield little financial or roster benefit at this stage.

What’s Next for Kyle Gibson?

At age 37, Kyle Gibson faces an uphill battle to regain his form. The Orioles are looking for improvement, and there’s still optimism that Gibson’s experience can help stabilize the rotation. However, with younger arms like Chayce McDermott and Trevor Rogers on the mend, Gibson’s place in the rotation may not be secure for long.

Ultimately, Gibson’s veteran presence can help in the clubhouse, but he will need to string together some quality starts to justify his role on the roster. Fans and analysts alike will be closely watching his next outings, wondering if he can bounce back or if his best days are behind him.

Conclusion

Kyle Gibson’s journey in 2025 illustrates just how unpredictable baseball careers can be. While the Cardinals’ decision to let him walk is proving wise, the Orioles are still hoping their investment will pay off. As the season unfolds, Gibson’s story remains a compelling example of the challenges faced by veteran pitchers in a league constantly evolving.

For more updates on Gibson and other MLB news, be sure to check the latest insights from trusted sources and keep an eye on how this veteran arm adapts to his new environment.