After a blockbuster offseason acquisition, expectations for Devin Williams with the New York Yankees soared. Yet, the opening weeks of his 2025 campaign proved to be a real challenge. For Yankees fans and baseball analysts alike, the question is clear: Can Devin Williams rediscover the dominant form that made him one of the most feared relievers in baseball?

Early Struggles After a High-Profile Trade

When the Yankees traded for Devin Williams, they banked on his reputation as an elite closer. In Milwaukee, Williams was a two-time All-Star, with a devastating change-up and shutdown ability in the ninth inning. The Yankees paid a premium for his services, sending Nestor Cortes and top prospect Caleb Durbin the other way.

However, Williams’ start in pinstripes didn’t go as planned. Over his first ten innings, he posted a 9.00 ERA—a far cry from his usual dominance. Hitters teed off on both his signature change-up and fastball, leaving fans worried about his rapid drop in effectiveness. According to a detailed breakdown from Empire Sports Media, even average hitters were performing well against his pitches, and his strikeout numbers dipped significantly.

Aaron Boone’s Strategic Shift

Recognizing the struggles, Yankees manager Aaron Boone made an important decision. Instead of continuing to use Williams in high-pressure closing situations, Boone moved him to a lower-leverage setup role. The move seemed risky, but it offered Williams the space to rebuild his confidence without the daily pressure of closing out games.

Recent outings suggest this pivot is working. Williams has delivered multiple scoreless innings in a row, including an eight-pitch, spotless performance against the Tampa Bay Rays. Boone expressed his optimism, stating he has been "really encouraged" by Williams’ bounce-back outings. For more on Boone’s thoughts and the team’s outlook, check out the New York Daily News analysis.

Can Devin Williams Reclaim the Closer Role?

The Yankees haven’t given up on Williams as their long-term bullpen solution. His pedigree and past performances signal high potential. Experts point out that relievers often need time and the right environment to regain their edge. The quieter setup role may give Williams exactly what he needs to sharpen his pitches and rebuild trust in his stuff.

As described by Athlon Sports, a successful turnaround could see Williams back in the closer role soon. It's not about replacing him, but restoring him to the elite level the Yankees traded for.

The Impact on the Yankees Bullpen

If Devin Williams continues to progress, the entire Yankees bullpen will benefit. His resurgence would not just solidify late-game leads but also give Boone more flexibility with his pitching staff. Williams’ story is a reminder that even star players face adversity, and turning things around often requires patience from both team and fans.

Conclusion: Betting on Talent and Resilience

Devin Williams’ journey with the Yankees is ongoing, marked by early turmoil and hopeful recoveries. With support from team leadership and adjustments in his role, he’s showing clear signs of a turnaround. For now, the Yankees are betting on his talent and resilience. If Williams continues on this path, his comeback story could become a highlight of the 2025 season.

Stay updated on Devin Williams’ performances and the Yankees’ bullpen strategy by following reliable baseball coverage through sources like New York Daily News and Empire Sports Media.