Cody Bellinger arrived in New York with big expectations. With his track record as a two-time All-Star, MVP, and Gold Glove winner, fans and analysts alike were eager to see if he could fill the void left by Juan Soto and help power the Yankees’ lineup. As the 2025 Major League Baseball season unfolds, Bellinger’s performance and contract decisions have become hot topics among Yankees supporters. In this article, we’ll examine Bellinger’s season so far, the contract dilemma hanging over him, and what it could mean for his future in pinstripes.

Cody Bellinger’s 2025 Performance: A Closer Look

After a promising spring, hopes were high that Cody Bellinger could bounce back offensively in 2025. However, through the first 36 games, Bellinger’s bat has been unusually quiet. He’s hitting just .221 and has totaled only 10 extra-base hits. This dip in production comes at a crucial time for the Yankees, who saw star slugger Aaron Judge step up while Bellinger continues to search for his rhythm at the plate.

It’s not just observers in New York raising concerns. An in-depth analysis from Sporting News highlights the pressure mounting on Bellinger. The Yankees needed him to replace Soto’s offensive production, but the results have yet to meet expectations. As a result, Yankees management faces a tough call if things don’t turn around soon.

The $26 Million Contract Decision Looms

Bellinger is currently in his second season of a three-year, $80 million deal that includes a crucial player option for 2026 valued at $25 million. If his offensive struggles continue, industry insiders predict Bellinger could opt in for another guaranteed year, rather than risking free agency after a down season. As Yahoo Sports explains, Bellinger’s decision is emblematic of a new trend in MLB’s volatile contract environment. With a soft market for hitters and uncertainty in long-term deals, taking the safe route could make the most sense for both Bellinger and the Yankees this off-season.

Throughout the spring and early part of the season, Bellinger's defensive skills have remained a key asset. He’s played exceptional defense across all outfield positions, preserving his value to the Yankees even as his offense lags. This all-around ability is likely keeping him in the Yankees' daily lineup, giving him opportunities to turn his season around.

What’s Next for Bellinger and the Yankees?

With the Yankees eyeing another playoff run and questions swirling around the outfield, the next few months will be pivotal for both Bellinger and the organization. If he can rediscover his powerful swing, he could still play a vital role in the Yankees’ postseason ambitions. Otherwise, as detailed in this MSN analysis, management may be forced into a difficult outfield decision—possibly even exploring trade options if the club wants to allocate salary elsewhere.

Conclusion: High Stakes for Cody Bellinger in New York

Cody Bellinger remains a player of immense talent and high expectations. While defensive excellence has kept him relevant, his offensive turnaround will ultimately shape his legacy in New York. The looming player option gives Bellinger control over his immediate future, but the Yankees must decide if they’re prepared to double down. For now, all eyes remain on Bellinger as he seeks to recapture his All-Star form and deliver for the Bronx Bombers.