Few names resonate with Pittsburgh Pirates fans quite like Andrew McCutchen. A former National League MVP and five-time All-Star, McCutchen's impact on both the team and the city has been profound. As the 2025 season progresses, a burning question emerges: Will Andrew McCutchen return to the Pirates in 2026?

McCutchen's 2025 Performance: Still Going Strong

Despite being 38 years old, Andrew McCutchen remains a key player in the Pirates' lineup. According to recent reports, his .255 batting average ranks third-highest on the team this season (Source). He also leads in several offensive categories like doubles, while maintaining solid on-base and slugging percentages. Even after so many years in the league, his production continues to defy age expectations, making fans hopeful for at least one more year.

For more details on his performance, check out this article covering his stats and value to the team.

Fan Sentiment: Do Pirates Fans Want Cutch Back?

Fan support for Andrew McCutchen remains as strong as ever. In a recent SB Nation Reacts poll, nearly 60 percent of respondents expressed their desire for McCutchen to return for the 2026 season (source). Many believe that, even if his statistics aren't at his former MVP level, his veteran leadership and presence in the clubhouse are invaluable.

If you’re curious about fan opinions and more in-depth reactions, read the full results of the SB Nation Reacts poll.

The Team's Perspective: Contract and Roster Decisions

Andrew McCutchen is currently signed through 2025, with his contract valued at $5 million for the year. Given the Pirates’ ongoing rebuilding process and their struggles this season, the front office faces a tough decision. Does the team focus solely on young talent, or do they retain a productive veteran who means so much to the fan base?

Another aspect to consider is roster flexibility. Recently, McCutchen sat out a game against the Mets, giving other hitters a chance to shine (read more on RotoWire). This demonstrates his willingness to adapt to a mentoring role if needed, a quality that could benefit the Pirates’ young prospects.

Looking Ahead: Legacy and Future

For many, Andrew McCutchen is more than just statistics. He symbolizes the heart and soul of Pittsburgh baseball over the past decade. Whether or not he returns for the 2026 season, his legacy is already secure. As the debate continues, Pittsburgh fans eagerly await updates and hope for one final, exciting chapter in McCutchen’s storied career.

Conclusion

Andrew McCutchen has proven he can still contribute on the field and inspire off of it. With solid performance, strong fan support, and a track record of leadership, the case for his 2026 return is compelling. As the offseason approaches, all eyes will be on the Pirates’ next move. Stay tuned for more updates as this story continues to unfold.